Posted on21 November 2016 10:03 AM GMT

The Shape of a Guitar's Headstock has a significant impact on Tuning Stability

Electric GuitarGuitar OwnershipGuitar HeadstockGuitar TuningGuitar Tuning FidelityTuning PegsTuning KeysMachine Heads+-
2016AfBlgGuitarHeadstocks700

Many a owner of a vintage guitar has experienced the difficulty of keeping the guitar in tune. There are a couple of factors here that are critical to tuning fidelity. Firstly, get over the hangup of having to use the original tuners - you really need locking tuners for any reasonable peace of mind. Locking tuners are available in a vast variety of shapes and types, including various vintage-inspired ones, so it should not prove to be problematic to find a near match that works well - not having to tune up 10 times a day should make it worth your while.

 

I have long held the view that all guitars should come with locking tuners - even those with Floyd Roses, as not only do locking machine heads maintain tuning for a lot longer - they make it 100% easier to re-string a guitar - so you’re getting dual benefits really. It is the first thing I look to replace when I get a guitar, along with Schaller strap locks.

 

In addition to the type of tuning pegs deployed, their alignment and layout on the headstock is equally critical for keeping a guitar in tune. The older guitars have essentially rectangular-shaped headstocks with the strings often running at fairly acute angles to and through the nut. For the nut to work optimally, the strings need to be able to glide in and out of the nut grooves effortlessly and without friction, which is why you really want the string running as perpendicular to the nut - or straight through the grooves. In the above visual you can see how for the Jackson, Rickenbacker, Gibson and Gretsch - the strings all enter their nut grooves at an angle. On Gibsons in particular, this leads to a common problem of sticking strings, which seriously impacts tuning fidelity.

 

For the older style guitars you need to deploy very hard-wearing and ideally self-lubricating graphite alloy nuts, as the strings will rub up against them more, and they need to be even more friction-less to ensure smooth glide-through of the strings. Every couple of years or so Gibson come up with a new and improved solution - currently in its latest titanium form (still not perfect!). But to be 100% sure with these types of headstocks you are best at employing a lubricant too, something like Big Bends Nut Sauce or Planet Waves LubriKit.

 

There is another less significant impact factor, and that is the distance or drop that the strings need to travel between tuners and nut. Guitars with tuning pegs all in one row (inline), often have to carry string trees or other physical guides to ensure that strings stay within their optimal lines of action. The very best headstock designs minimise the string drop by having the tuners closer to the nut. The best known examples of this are the 4+2 Music Man layout, and the 3+3 PRS layout. In effect you really need a tapered headstock of trapezoid or triangular shape. Schecter, Kiesel / Carvin, ESP, Jackson and many other manufacturers deploy variants of these shapes - even Gibson does it for its Flying V range.

 

PRS pretty much utilizes the same headstock shape throughout its range, as does Music Man with its own - both of these to ensure optimal tuning fidelity and ultimate performance at all times. People buy Gibsons for their classic tone and looks, but get lumbered with tuning problems. If you are a journeying musician without an army of techs at your beck and call, it probably makes sense to rely on a an instrument with a more modern headstock. Fender. Ibanez and other purveyors of inline headstocks are a significant step above the traditional brigade, but for the very best performance you need either a modern tapered 4+2 or 3+3 arrangement.

 

The above visual features some of the best known headstocks in declining order of tuning performance - i.e. best at the top - there is no significance to ranking in the left-to right axis. I just thought it would be nice to have the current big 3 down the central spine - PRS > Fender > Gibson ...

 

P.S. - I still love the look of the new 2017 Gibson Les Paul Standard HP - whose headstock is featured here! I will see next year if this becomes my next guitar, I am certainly up for the challenge. I like the sound of the G-Force Auto-Tuning, but I don’t like the fact that its tuners are not the locking type - meaning you have to rely on the imperfect system of wrapping strings around the post, so that even with automatic tuning, the fundamentals are somewhat flawed - and it takes longer to re-string etc. than a locking tuner. They really should have built-in a top-locking version like PRS’s tuning keys have, that would have worked rather well...

Stefan
Posted by Stefan
Popular Comments RSS Feed Content Subscriptions
Tweet Facebook LinkedIn Tumblr Pinterest Google+
Add New Comment
You must be logged in to comment.

Did you find this content useful?

Thank you for your input

Thank you for your feedback

Blog Navigation


2017 50

House Music Label Odyssey
"Thanks for sharing this article , I am making an "...
25-Oct-2017
4 Key GDPR Questions that still need Answering
"Thanks for that update Markus. It would also be "...
19-Oct-2017
9 of the Best Compressor Pedals for Your Consideration
"Hiram - I believe it's the OTA / Ross Compressor T"...
01-Oct-2017
9 of the Best Compressor Pedals for Your Consideration
"Great post! What kind of compression does the C"...
01-Oct-2017
Affino 8 Coming July 2017
"We've pushed this back for a number of great "...
27-Sep-2017
Affino and GDPR
"Hi James, we will be working on the Suspend side, "...
20-Sep-2017
BOSS is quite literally Bossing things again these days
"This is the best information. If you want to "...
13-Sep-2017
Waiting

Related Articles

Driving business at some of the world's most forward thinking companies

Rovio
IDG
Procurement Leaders
Ocean Media Group
Gill
Drewry
Shard Media Group
PPA
AOP - Association of Publishers
Briefing Media
IMRG
FG Insight
Internet Retailing
TTG

Our Chosen Charity

Humanity Direct

And delivering industry leading awards

2016 British Media Awards - Technology Provide of the Year - Silver
2014 PPA Connect Awards - Procurement Leaders awarded Event Brand of the Year
2014 PPA Digital Publishing Awards - Procurement Leaders awarded Business Media Digital Brand of the Year (Again!)
2014 PPA Awards - Procurement Leaders awarded Business Media Brand of the Year (Again!)
2014 AOP Digital Publishing Awards - Procurement Leaders awarded Best Business to Business Website
2013 PPA Awards - Procurement Leaders awarded Independent Publisher Digital Product of the Year
2013 PPA Awards - Procurement Leaders awarded Business Media Brand of the Year
2013 PPA Digital Publishing Awards - Procurement Leaders awarded Business Media Digital Brand of the Year
Let Us Call You Back
Contact Us
Request A Demo